Your complete HRMS payroll software guide


Sorting your HRMS payroll can seem rather daunting. Payroll is one of the most important aspects of your business, when it's running smoothly - no one mentions it, but when there is a problem with an employee's paycheck then it's a significant issue that needs to be fixed as quickly as possible.

These days, it’s common to find payroll bundled up in the features of an HRMS. It makes perfect sense in terms of data. Most HRMS options include time and attendance, workforce scheduling and absence management; exactly the data needed to calculate payroll. 

What’s more, there are also opportunities – with more sophisticated systems – to draw on performance statistics and venture into the world of predictive analytics, comparing performance and rewards, accurately identifying your high-flyers, and even profiling them for characteristics that can be fed into your recruitment campaigns.

This guide will provide you with an overview of the core differences between HRMS payroll and ERP payroll, and the advantages and disadvantages of using HR software for payroll. And, a selection of very useful links to other HRMS World payroll resources that should answer any questions raised as you read on…

What is HRMS payroll?

At its most basic, an HRMS payroll function will calculate and pay salaries, withhold the appropriate taxes and deductions, and organize the printing and delivery of paychecks. However, many HRMS software vendors include extra abilities.

But if you’re faced with the choice of purchasing either an HRMS that includes payroll, a standalone solution, or payroll wrapped up in an ERP system, there are a few factors – and pros and cons – to consider.

Check out our guide to managing your HRMS payroll to learn more about integrating payroll, compliance, and automation

Differences between HRMS payroll and other systems

Automating HRMS payroll carries clear advantages, including:

  • Easy access to compensation and reward data
  • Less need for data input (if the information is already in a system, then the payroll software can be set up to access it, ensuring single input)
  • A reduction in staffing time and overheads
  • A coordinated approach that doesn’t rely on a collection of databases, files, and spreadsheets

Which automation option you choose depends, as ever, on the business needs of your organization but there are some broad factors that should influence your decision.

  1. Integration: whether part of a single HRMS or a standalone module, your payroll needs access to relevant data to do its thing. That means integration, whether as part of a single package or through smooth access to the information kept in its ‘sister systems’. But more than simple access to data, integration includes following through on the implications of events or actions. For example, booking an employee onto a training event should automatically take them off the work schedule during the event; it should also trigger pay-related consequences, such as payment of additional supplements or different rates.
  2. User experience: as with any software, the UX is critical. Is it user-friendly? Does it process quickly enough to avoid frustration? Are relevant updates made seamlessly, giving users confidence in the system? A useful perspective is to view a system according to the quality of its self-service options. Are they easily understood by users? Do they add real value and convenience for users?

What is a payroll module?

A payroll module is usually an extension or add-on to a core HRMS system. Many HRMS software vendors offer a payroll module for customers who want extra support with their payroll management. 

HRMS payroll advantages

So, what’s in it for you to opt for HRMS payroll?

  • Compatibility: when all the data is kept in the same system, and staffing details (names, numbers, bank accounts and so on) are kept up to date by the employees themselves, payroll errors are reduced, including the possibility of over or underpayment. For payroll, this is basic-but-essential stuff, paying people correctly.
  • Single portal access: if all HR-related systems are accessed from the same point, the ease of the user experience is improved. Whether it’s a worker wanting to check their paycheck, or a CFO interpreting the figures ready for a board meeting, you’re looking for something intuitive and simple (and preferably, in line with your other business systems in terms of usability).
  • More secure data: your payroll records contain a great deal of sensitive personal information (including social security numbers, bank account details, and salary figures). When all such data is kept in the same secure location, the risk of a security breach or data loss is minimized.
  • More accurate data: an HRMS payroll, by virtue of its integration, means fewer errors. This means, consequently, less staff time spent on correcting such errors.
  • Less opportunity for ‘deliberate errors’: the administration of timesheets and time and attendance by the same system usually means a closer focus on such recordkeeping and therefore less chance of time theft or other fraud.
  • Cost: total cost of ownership includes far more than the figure on the system’s price tag, incorporating a number of costs that may be somewhat less obvious. Naturally, one system that includes all your HR functions will be less expensive than buying two or more systems and then persuading them to talk to one another.
  • Compliance: a significant benefit of any automated business system is improved legislative and regulatory compliance. However, as the relevant labor laws change, the right HRMS payroll module will keep you on the right side of official scrutiny.

Potential disadvantages of using HRMS payroll

  • All the eggs are in one basket: dealing with a single system and vendor can be convenient, less complicated, and more cost-effective. However, the flip side is that should the system crash or otherwise cause problems, everything and everyone is at risk of a payroll error. If business continuity is of special importance, then keeping systems separate might be a better move.
  • Not all payroll is the same: some larger companies may have different departments handling their own payroll. If so, the likelihood is that those different departments have different systems, differing priorities, and even different attitudes. Any move to bring everyone together in a new way of doing things is likely to encounter teething troubles, resistance, and miscommunication.
  • Setup costs: yes, payroll integrated with your HRMS is often a good thing and offers longer-term cost savings, but making the shift can be expensive upfront. For example, a new system often means user training and more in-depth training for those HR staff who must administer the system. As with any technology purchase, before you start, be sure that the investment is likely to pay off.

Top HRMS payroll systems

Though different organizations’ needs and requirements will of course vary, this is a shortlist of well-established vendors providing HRMS with payroll included to start you off:

APS Payroll
APS stands for Automatic Payroll Systems, which is a bit of an indicator of the company’s history and of its strong focus on payroll management. APS Payroll is a leading name in the field and its software offers streamlined payroll functionality integrated with the expected HR processes, including time and attendance, recruitment, and absence management. A variety of employee and manager self-service features are available, including via mobile.

Check out our guide to HRMS, ERP, and payroll to determine which system you should use for your payroll

A well-established vendor specializing in small to medium-sized businesses, BambooHR’s cloud-based platform includes payroll. With multiple language and currency options, the system may be particularly well-suited to organizations with a global reach.

UKG Ready
Another long-standing brand, UKG Ready (formerly Kronos Workforce Ready) is cloud-based and offers payroll alongside recruiting, onboarding, performance management, compensation planning, time and attendance, scheduling, and absence management.

A fully configurable, all-in-one HR, talent management, and payroll system, UKG Pro (formerly UltiPro) is used to handling millions of employee records across its combined cloud accounts.

ADP Workforce Now
Another ‘big name’ in payroll and HRMS, Automatic Data Processing may be the oldest name in workplace automation, combining payroll with benefits management, compliance, and a range of analytics and benchmarking functionality. All modules use a single database for reduced input and administration and users have a range of self-service options.

Zoho Payroll
Designed for federal and state tax compliance, Zoho Payroll can effortlessly automate your payroll processes, saving time and money. It’s affordable, easy to use, and is integrated with Zoho’s accounting software, Zoho Books. 

Sage Payroll comes either as part of Sage HRMS or as standalone payroll software. Highly flexible and easily adaptable to any business, Sage’s Payroll service eliminates any time-consuming manual processes.

Any employer needs reliable payroll and the business case for automation (fewer errors, greater efficiency, reduced costs) is hard to beat. Though it may not be the best option for every organization, HRMS payroll software is usually an easy option with possibilities for wider benefits, linking as it does your payroll calculations to your wider HR activity.


author image
Dave Foxall

About the author…

Dave has worked as HR Manager for the Ministry of Justice for a number of years, he now writes on a broad range of topics including jazz music, and, of course, the HRMS software market.

author image
Dave Foxall

Featured white papers

Related articles